Be aware that "Hadith 3714" in other major collections refers to entirely different topics. For instance, Sahih al-Bukhari 3714 discusses the virtues of Fatima. Sunnah.com of the term in classical Arabic?
Verification of a companion's presence in Medina during the drafting of the Constitution of Medina. tabaqat al kubra. vol. 3 pg. 269 h. 3714
To understand the weight of page 269, we must first appreciate the author. Muhammad ibn Sa‘d was a Katib (scribe) and student of the legendary traditionist al-Waqidi (d. 207 AH). Born in Basra, Ibn Sa‘d later settled in Baghdad, the epicenter of the Islamic Golden Age. His Tabaqat is not merely a hadith collection; it is a comprehensive prosopography —a biographical dictionary that classifies over 4,000 early Muslim figures into hierarchical generations ( tabaqat ). Be aware that "Hadith 3714" in other major
A very specific and intriguing request!
The chain begins with "Muhammad ibn ‘Umar (al-Waqidi)" . Al-Waqidi, Ibn Sa‘d’s teacher, is a polarizing figure. Hadith critics (like al-Shafi‘i and Ahmad ibn Hanbal) accused him of being a weak narrator, unreliable in the sahih traditions. However, Ibn Sa‘d uses al-Waqidi as his primary source for biographical information, not for establishing legal rulings. Page 269 shows that even when citing al-Waqidi in a hadith context, Ibn Sa‘d preserves the matn (text) for historical, not legal, evidence. This distinction is critical: Tabaqat is a work of Tarikh (history), not Sahih (authenticity). Verification of a companion's presence in Medina during
Utilizziamo i cookie per personalizzare contenuti ed annunci, per fornire funzionalità dei social media e per analizzare il nostro traffico. Condividiamo inoltre informazioni sul modo in cui utilizza il nostro sito con i nostri partner che si occupano di analisi dei dati web, pubblicità e social media, i quali potrebbero combinarle con altre informazioni che ha fornito loro o che hanno raccolto dal suo utilizzo dei loro servizi