Eminem: - We Made You Upd

Critically, however, the reaction was mixed to negative. Many reviewers felt the song was a step backward. Pitchfork gave it a scathing review, calling it "tired and predictable." Rolling Stone noted that while the track was fun, it felt like Eminem was going through the motions. Fans were divided, too. Those who loved the irreverent "Without Me" style embraced it. Those hoping for the deep introspection of "Stan" or "When I'm Gone" were disappointed.

When Eminem returned after a four-year hiatus with Relapse , fans didn’t know whether to expect the introspective “Beautiful” or the horrorcore of “3 a.m.” Instead, the lead single served up vintage Slim Shady: rapid-fire punchlines, absurd accents, and a music video that roasted everyone from Britney Spears to Kim Kardashian. eminem - we made you

Dr. Dre and Eminem remixed the track heavily, transforming Charmagne Tripp 's chorus vocals from a vintage sound into a polished pop hook. 2. The Amy Winehouse Connection Critically, however, the reaction was mixed to negative

Eminem originally wanted to sing the hook herself. Fans were divided, too